"They Look Nothing Like Instagram"... Reactions Shift After Face of 'Pretty So She's Innocent' Motel Murder Suspect Is Revealed

Publicly released photo of So-Young Kim, suspect in the 'Gangbuk Motel Drug Incident' (right), and photos from an SNS account presumed to be hers. Online community

원본보기 아이콘

Following the public disclosure of So-Young Kim’s identity, the suspect in the "Gangbuk Motel Drug Death Incident," a new wave of debate has emerged online. In the early stages of the case, posts that glamorized or sympathized with the perpetrator based on her appearance spread widely. However, after her identity was revealed, the trend shifted, with people mocking or comparing her looks instead.

Experts point out that this phenomenon could lead to yet another form of "perpetrator-centric narrative," where the case is consumed through the lens of the perpetrator’s appearance. There are growing concerns that discussions about the seriousness of the crime and the victim are disappearing, leaving only evaluations and ridicule of the perpetrator’s looks, which distorts the essence of the incident and could lead to secondary victimization.

Kim's image captured on CCTV (right) and a photo from an SNS account presumed to be his. Screenshot from an online community and Channel A news broadcast.

원본보기 아이콘

On March 9, the Seoul Northern District Prosecutors’ Office publicly disclosed the name, age, and mug shot (a record photograph of a criminal suspect) of So-Young Kim (20), the suspect in the "Gangbuk Motel Drug Serial Murder" case. In accordance with the Serious Crime Suspect Disclosure Act, prosecutors can refer suspects accused of serious crimes to the Suspect Information Disclosure Deliberation Committee to determine whether to make their personal information public.

After this, photos of Kim quickly began to spread on various social networking services (SNS). In particular, numerous posts appeared evaluating or mocking her appearance by comparing the publicly released photo with older SNS photos.

Earlier, at the beginning of the case, photos presumed to be from Kim’s SNS account were shared online, sparking controversy as comments praising her appearance or defending her actions proliferated. Some netizens left comments such as, "Would any man refuse if a woman like her asked to go to a motel first?" "She’s pretty, so she’s innocent," "I would have gone too," "Consider her looks when sentencing," and "Let’s set up a donation account."

Photos from an SNS account presumed to belong to Mr. Kim. Online community

원본보기 아이콘

However, after her identity was disclosed, the online atmosphere shifted dramatically once again. Comparing her past SNS photos with the official disclosed photo, comments such as "Fooled by photo editing" and "She looks completely different from her Instagram photos" began to appear. Other mocking remarks included, "I take back my comment about following her to a motel," and "She looks much older than 20."

Netizens' Reactions After Identity Revealed. Screenshot from Naver News

원본보기 아이콘

Nevertheless, such reactions themselves are being criticized as problematic, as they still focus on the perpetrator’s appearance. Experts warn that interpreting or consuming a crime primarily through the lens of the perpetrator’s looks can distort the fundamental nature of the case.

Especially in cases where initial reactions glamorize the perpetrator due to her looks, and later reactions turn to ridicule, the perpetrator’s image can end up attracting more public attention than the seriousness of the crime itself.

Experts emphasize, "When the perpetrator’s appearance or image is excessively consumed, the seriousness of the crime can be diluted and empathy for the victim and their family may decrease." They add, "It is essential that both crime reporting and online discourse maintain a victim-centered perspective."

© The Asia Business Daily(www.asiae.co.kr). All rights reserved.